1. Sooo it won’t let me finish the quest, I literally did all that and she is just sitting on the dock telling me I am no help lol. After every fish I catch I go back to her and she just repeats herself every time. 🙁

    1. Agree! I have only one quest left to get the Platinum Trophy on this and I can’t complete it because of a bug. And it’s a game-breaking one.

  2. Saved game while in the “middle” of fishing. Did a load up of the same save, Walter and Nel were behind me on the dock arguing. Hope this helps.

  3. Must be FISHING. Shooting the fish wont work. I literally shot 30 fish (so my entire quiver of arrows) to no avail. Finished the quest on my 3rd fish i caught on a line.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *